The Structure of Mental Health Crisis Among Young People — Background to 340,000 School Refusals and the Worst Suicide Rate in G7

What is Happening

In fiscal year 2023, the number of elementary and junior high school students refusing to attend school reached 346,482. This represents an increase of approximately 47,000 from the previous year, setting a new record high. The rate of increase is about 2.7 times that of ten years ago.

While this figure alone is serious, the full scope of the problem extends much further. The number of suicides among elementary, junior high, and high school students in 2022 was 514, a record high. In 2023, it remained high at 513. Japan is the only G7 country where suicide is the leading cause of death among people aged 15-34.

School refusal and suicide may appear to be different problems on the surface. However, they share a common underlying structure. The compound deterioration of environments where young people experience "difficulty in living"—changes occurring in schools, families, and society—may be exceeding individuals' adaptive limits.

Background and Context

School as a "Place of Excessive Adaptation"

The most frequently cited reason for school refusal is "apathy and anxiety," accounting for 51.8% of all cases. Cases with clear causes such as bullying (0.3%) or problems with teachers (1.4%) are in the minority, with many children in a state where "they don't understand why they can't go to school."

This increase in "ambiguous school refusal" suggests rising adaptation costs to the school system itself. Uniform curricula, strong peer pressure in group life, and long hours of confinement through club activities—these are products of the "Japanese-style school model" formed during the period of high economic growth, and the mismatch with diversifying characteristics and needs of children is expanding.

The Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology formulated the "COCOLO Plan" in 2023, setting out policies to expand the establishment of special schools for non-attending students and ensure learning opportunities using ICT. However, as of fiscal year 2024, there are only 35 special schools for non-attending students nationwide, which is overwhelmingly insufficient as a solution for 340,000 students.

Functional Changes in Families and "Poverty of Connection"

The most basic social unit supporting children's mental health is the family. However, the function of families is undergoing structural transformation.

Dual-income households numbered 12.78 million in 2023 (about 70% of households with married couples). An estimated over 3 million children spend time alone after school as "latchkey kids." There are about 1.42 million single-parent households, with 54.6% in relative poverty. As physical contact time decreases and economic stress increases simultaneously, families are finding it increasingly difficult to function as safety nets.

Furthermore, the spread of SNS is changing the quality of human relationships. According to a Cabinet Office survey, smartphone ownership among junior and senior high school students exceeds 98%, with an average daily usage time of over 4 hours. Online troubles (cyberbullying, slander, self-denial through comparison) function as stress sources in a different dimension from face-to-face relationship difficulties.

Capacity Limits of Psychiatric Care

The medical system responding to mental health crises among young people is also under strain. There are approximately 500 child psychiatrists nationwide. The average waiting period for initial consultations is 3-6 months, with some regions reporting waits of over a year.

While the deployment of school counselors has progressed, most work part-time, once a week. We are far from having psychological specialists stationed full-time in schools. Teachers themselves are also overworked, with about 36% of all teachers working more than 80 hours of overtime per month. There is a structural contradiction here where "those who provide support" are themselves exhausted.

Reading the Structure

Attributing the mental health crisis among young people to "individual weakness" or "parental responsibility" is nothing but making the structure invisible.

First Structure—"Time Gap Between System and Reality". Japan's school system is designed based on the human resource development model of industrial society. The premise of learning discipline and cooperation within homogeneous groups creates institutional mismatches in a society where individual diversity has expanded. The figure of 340,000 school refusals should be read not as children being "broken," but as the manifestation of the system "becoming unable to respond."

Second Structure—"Multiple Collapse of Safety Nets". Multiple networks supporting young people—families, schools, communities, and medical care—are simultaneously experiencing functional decline. Time poverty in families due to dual-income arrangements, loss of school capacity due to teacher overwork, weakening of regional communities, and chronic shortages in child psychiatry. Problems that could be endured if any one of these functioned become concentrated on individuals when all weaken simultaneously.

Third Structure—"Imbalance Between Prevention and Intervention". Current measures are heavily weighted toward "intervention" after problems become manifest. Support after becoming school refusal cases, responses after suicide attempts, treatment after onset of mental illness. Investment in preventive approaches—introduction of social-emotional learning (SEL), resilience education, early screening—is systematically insufficient. Systematic institutional introduction of evidence-based prevention programs like Finland's "KiVa Program" or Australia's "Beyondblue" is needed.

The numbers continue to issue warnings. 340,000 school refusals, 514 child suicides, the worst youth suicide rate in G7. Whether these are processed as "abnormal values" or reflected in institutional design as "structural consequences" will determine the survival environment for the next generation.

• The "Depth" of Child Poverty — What Relative Poverty Rates Cannot Tell
• NPO Organizational Assessment Guide — Practical Methods for Organizational Diagnosis

References

令和5年度 児童生徒の問題行動・不登校等生徒指導上の諸課題に関する調査結果

文部科学省. 文部科学省

Read source

令和5年中における自殺の状況

厚生労働省・警察庁. 厚生労働省

Read source

誰一人取り残されない学びの保障に向けた不登校対策（COCOLOプラン）

文部科学省. 文部科学省

Read source

子供・若者白書 令和6年版

内閣府. 内閣府

Read source