Agnotology Lab — Structural Analysis of Informational Injustice and Counter-Design
Research dissecting the mechanisms by which advertising, propaganda, media, education, religion, and authority structurally produce and maintain ignorance, reexamining social issues through the lens of agnotology.
Background
Why do we remain ignorant — and is it by accident or by design? Through the lens of agnotology, we dissect the mechanisms by which advertising, propaganda, media, education, religion, and authority produce and maintain ignorance, reexamining social issues and current affairs from an academic perspective.
Research Artifacts
Progress map of frameworks and deliverables for each phase. Click a slot to expand related notes.
Foundations
0/4Framework
Conceptual Framework
Literature Map
Deliverable
Key Concepts
Critique
0/3Framework
Critique Framework
Deliverable
Case Analysis
Critique Notes
Synthesis
0/3Framework
Synthesis Framework
Deliverable
Theory Notes
Counter-Design Proposal
Publication
0/3Framework
Publication Outline
Deliverable
Academic Paper
Public Report
Discourse
0/3Discourse Article
Lecture Materials
Educational Tools
Methodology
Research methodology and approaches adopted in this lab.
Critical Literature Review
Systematically reviewing prior work in agnotology, epistemology, media studies and education, then extracting and classifying the mechanisms by which ignorance is deliberately produced, along several coding axes.
Conceptual Analysis
Philosophically analysing the conceptual boundaries between ignorance, non-knowledge and the unknowable, and clarifying qualitative differences in ignorance across cases.
Glossary
Key terms and definitions used in this research.
- Agnotology
- The study of how ignorance is deliberately produced and maintained. Proposed by R. N. Proctor in 2008.
- Related terms:Strategic IgnoranceEpistemic Injustice
- Source
- Brandolini's Law
- The rule of thumb that refuting misinformation takes an order of magnitude more energy than producing it. Also called the bullshit asymmetry principle.
- Related terms:Post-TruthFirehose of Falsehood
- Design Science Research (DSR)
- A problem-solving research methodology that accumulates knowledge by designing and evaluating artifacts such as frameworks, taxonomies and models. Formalised by Hevner (2007).
- Related terms:Agnotology
- Source
- Epistemic Injustice
- A wrong in which a speaker's testimony is unfairly discounted because of their social attributes (gender, race, occupation and so on). Systematised by M. Fricker in 2007.
- Related terms:AgnotologyTestimonial Injustice
- Source
- Ethics Washing
- Self-regulation that puts on the appearance of ethics and is used in place of accountability that actually bites. In the AI industry, framings such as responsible AI and human-centred AI serve this purpose.
- Related terms:Regulatory CaptureStrategic Ignorance
- Source
- Firehose of Falsehood
- A propaganda technique that releases large volumes of falsehood at high speed across many channels, saturating the audience's capacity to verify. Named by the RAND Corporation in 2016.
- Related terms:Brandolini's LawPropaganda
- Government Complicity
- The bidirectional side of regulatory capture, completed when the regulators themselves — not the regulated — actively adopt the industry's narrative. Named by Birhane et al. (2026).
- Related terms:Regulatory Capture
- Source
- Hermeneutical Injustice
- One form of epistemic injustice: socially marginalised groups being unfairly deprived of the conceptual resources to understand and articulate their own experience.
- Related terms:Epistemic InjusticeTestimonial Injustice
- Merchants of Doubt
- Strategic actors who deliberately manufacture doubt against scientific consensus in order to delay policy decisions. Named by Oreskes & Conway (2010).
- Related terms:Strategic IgnoranceAgnotology
- Pluralistic Ignorance
- Individuals privately holding doubts, wrongly assuming that others hold none, and therefore staying silent. The cognitive basis of the Japanese kuuki (the mood in the room) and of conformity pressure.
- Related terms:Post-Truth
- Post-Truth
- A condition in which emotion and personal belief carry more weight in shaping public opinion than objective fact. Oxford Dictionaries made it word of the year in 2016.
- Related terms:Brandolini's LawAgnotology
- Regulatory Capture
- A phenomenon in which industry effectively dominates the regulator, so that rules meant to serve the public interest work for industry instead. Theorised economically by Stigler (1971).
- Related terms:Strategic IgnoranceAgnotology
- Source
- Sleeper Effect
- The psychological phenomenon whereby information from a low-credibility source is remembered detached from that source over time, so its persuasive force rises after the fact. The cognitive basis of the firehose strategy.
- Related terms:Firehose of FalsehoodBrandolini's Law
- Sociology of Non-Knowledge
- A branch of sociology that analyses ignorance as socially constituted. Developed by U. Beck, M. Gross and P. Wehling. Complements agnotology.
- Related terms:AgnotologyStrategic Ignorance
- Sontaku
- The Japanese practice of acting on a presumed intention from above without any explicit instruction. Structurally similar to Proctor's ignorance as passive construction: not asking is what produces the ignorance.
- Related terms:Pluralistic Ignorance
- Strategic Ignorance
- Policymakers or companies deliberately obstructing the production and circulation of inconvenient knowledge. Theorised by L. McGoey.
- Related terms:AgnotologyEBPM
- Testimonial Injustice
- One form of epistemic injustice: testimony that is not judged on its merits because of prejudice against the group the speaker belongs to.
- Related terms:Epistemic InjusticeHermeneutical Injustice
- White Ignorance
- The epistemological ignorance that a white-supremacist society structurally maintains: a social contract to treat the historical consequences of colonial rule and slavery as unknown. Formulated by C. W. Mills (1997).
- Related terms:Epistemic InjusticeAgnotology
Bibliography
Detailed reference list for this research.
Big AI's Regulatory Capture: Mapping Industry Interference and Government Complicity
Birhane, A., Angius, R., Agnew, W., Pandit, H. J., Mitra, B., Dobbe, R., & Talat, Z. (2026)
An empirical study classifying regulatory capture in the AI industry into five categories and 27 mechanisms, analysing 249 cases across 100 articles. Uses the Design Science Research methodology. To be presented at FAccT'26 (25-28 June 2026, Montreal). The main reference for this lab's note synthesis-big-ai-regulatory-capture
How Silicon Valley Uses Big Tobacco, Pharma, and Oil Tactics to Block Regulation
Tech Policy Press (2026)
An analysis piece explaining the 27-mechanism study of Birhane et al. (2026) for the US policy community. Stresses the genealogical continuity between the regulatory-lobbying tactics of the tobacco, pharmaceutical and oil industries and those of the AI industry
無知学への招待 — 〈知らないこと〉を問い直す (Invitation to Agnotology: Rethinking Not Knowing)
鶴田想人, 塚原東吾（編著） (2025)
The first systematic introduction in Japanese. Four parts: overview, key terms, agnotology in Japan, and forms of ignorance
現代思想 2023年6月号 特集＝無知学／アグノトロジーとは何か (Gendai Shisō, June 2023: What Is Agnotology?)
隠岐さや香, 塚原東吾, 鶴田想人 ほか (2023)
The first special issue to discuss agnotology from several angles in Japanese, with contributions from history of science, philosophy, law, anthropology and gender history
認識的不正義 — 権力は知ることの倫理にどのようにかかわるのか (Japanese translation of Fricker 2007)
Fricker, M.（佐藤邦政 監訳, 飯塚理恵 訳） (2023)
The Japanese translation of Fricker (2007), Keiso Shobo
沖縄基地問題とアグノトロジーの視点からの課題 (The Okinawa Base Problem: Questions from an Agnotological Perspective)
西山秀史 (2023)
An analysis of mainland Japanese structural ignorance about Okinawa. In Gendai Shisō, June 2023
無知研究の諸相 — 無知学・無知の社会学・無知の認識論 (Facets of Ignorance Studies: Agnotology, the Sociology of Ignorance, the Epistemology of Ignorance)
鶴田想人, 岡本江里菜, 村瀬泰菜 (2022)
Introduction to the special section “Forms of Manufactured Ignorance”, Journal of History of Science Japan, vol. 61, no. 303
『アグノトロジー』を振り返る — 科学史の中の「無知研究」のこれまでとこれから (Looking Back on Agnotology: Ignorance Studies in the History of Science, Past and Future)
飯田香穂里 (2022)
A critical re-examination of the concept of agnotology, pointing out the problem of its bias towards deliberate ignorance
アグノトロジーと非知社会学 (Agnotology and the Sociology of Non-Knowledge)
井口暁 (2022)
Repositions agnotology from the standpoint of strategic ignorance and the sociology of non-knowledge (Gross, Wehling)
バカと無知 — 人間、この不都合な生きもの (Fools and Ignorance: The Inconvenient Creature That Is Man)
橘玲 (2022)
Explains, around the Dunning-Kruger effect, the mechanism by which the less someone knows the more confident they are. Analyses how a sense of justice and self-esteem reproduce ignorance
西洋ジェンダー史が向き合う無知、創り出す無知 (The Ignorance Western Gender History Confronts, and the Ignorance It Creates)
弓削尚子 (2022)
Journal of History of Science Japan, vol. 61, no. 303. The intersection of queer history and agnotology
Nudge: The Final Edition
Thaler, R. H. & Sunstein, C. R. (2022)
Libertarian paternalism. Choice architecture premised on rational ignorance — it can be turned to good ends or bad. The lab used the Japanese translation (Nikkei BP, 2022)
正欲 (Seiyoku)
朝井リョウ (2021)
A society that flies the banner of diversity certifies only certain desires as legitimate, and does not even imagine those who fall outside. A literary rendering of epistemic exclusion
障害者差別を問いなおす (Rethinking Discrimination Against Disabled People)
荒井裕樹 (2020)
Examines the history and present of discrimination against disabled people. The structure by which society does not listen to disabled voices — a Japanese case of testimonial injustice
Calling Bullshit: The Art of Skepticism in a Data-Driven World
Bergstrom, C. T. & West, J. D. (2020)
The Unknowers: How Strategic Ignorance Rules the World
McGoey, L. (2019)
A theorisation of strategic ignorance: the power structure of feigned not-knowing in the pharmaceutical industry and in philanthrocapitalism
The Knowledge Illusion: Why We Never Think Alone
Sloman, S. & Fernbach, P. (2018)
Individual knowledge is startlingly shallow; we lean on a community of knowledge and mistake it for our own understanding. Explains from cognitive science why individuals cannot notice structural ignorance. The lab used the Japanese translation (Hayakawa, 2018)
Post-Truth
McIntyre, L. (2018)
A philosophical analysis of post-truth, from science denialism to fake news
The Russian 'Firehose of Falsehood' Propaganda Model
Paul, C. & Matthews, M. (2016)
The Russian propaganda model, with four properties: high volume, high speed, many channels, and no commitment to consistency
言ってはいけない — 残酷すぎる真実 (Things You Must Not Say: Truths Too Cruel)
橘玲 (2016)
Presents scientific findings on heredity, intelligence and appearance that society seals off as unsayable. Empirical evidence of how taboo produces structural ignorance
Routledge International Handbook of Ignorance Studies
Gross, M. & McGoey, L. (eds.) (2015)
A handbook of ignorance studies, systematically covering the sociology of non-knowledge, strategic ignorance and organisational ignorance
最貧困女子 (Women in Deepest Poverty)
鈴木大介 (2014)
Women who have lost all three ties — family, community and institution — are excluded from information too, and cannot even come to know their options. A spiral in which poverty enforces ignorance and ignorance reproduces poverty
Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Global Warming
Oreskes, N. & Conway, E. M. (2011)
Tobacco, climate change, ozone depletion — exposes how the same group of scientists manufactured doubt for industry. The lab used the Japanese translation (Rakuhoku, 2011)
Golden Holocaust: Origins of the Cigarette Catastrophe and the Case for Abolition
Proctor, R. N. (2011)
The definitive account of ignorance manufacture by the tobacco industry, and of the “doubt is our product” strategy in full
日本の難点 (Japan's Sticking Points)
宮台真司 (2009)
A sociological diagnosis of the mechanism, specific to Japan, by which a culture of reading the room silences dissent and maintains collective ignorance
Agnotology: The Making and Unmaking of Ignorance
Proctor, R. N. & Schiebinger, L. (2008)
The founding work of agnotology. An empirical analysis of the tobacco industry's deliberate production of scientific ignorance
Doubt is Their Product: How Industry's Assault on Science Threatens Your Health
Michaels, D. (2008)
Systematises the patterns by which industry distorts regulatory science. An insider's view from a former head of OSHA
Epistemic Injustice: Power and the Ethics of Knowing
Fricker, M. (2007)
The foundational text systematising the two forms: testimonial injustice and hermeneutical injustice
The Racial Contract
Mills, C. W. (1997)
The original source of the concept of white ignorance. A white-supremacist society carries an epistemological contract — an agreement about what is to be treated as unknown
「空気」の研究 (A Study of Kuuki: The Mood in the Room)
山本七平 (1977)
Kuuki is the Japanese form of structural ignorance — the mechanism that tacitly fixes what may not be asked
権威と権力 — いうことをきかせる原理・きく原理 (Authority and Power: The Principle of Making Others Obey, and of Obeying)
なだいなだ (1974)
A psychiatrist analyses obedience to authority in dialogue with high-school students. A classic on how authority implants the belief that one has no need to know, and thereby maintains and reproduces ignorance
Academic Roadmap
Society memberships, paper submissions, and presentation plans.
Working Paper ISVD-WP-2026-001: An Inductive Research Framework for Agnotology
Zenodo
Zenodo DOI取得 → 引用可能な学術文献化。synthesis-big-ai-regulatory-capture (2026-05-20) を Chapter 4 として組み込み予定
Poster presentation at the JSSTS Annual Meeting
JSSTS
“Mechanisms That Produce Structural Ignorance — An Inductive Case Analysis”
Join the Japanese Society for Science and Technology Studies (JSSTS)
JSSTS
The home society shared by both labs. Full membership ¥8,000/year
LinkOther Notes (24)
What Is Silence-Structuring? — The Architecture of Pluralistic Ignorance
The Reproduction of Authority and Ignorance — The Structure of 'No Need to Know'
Motivated Ignorance — The Cognitive Structure of 'Not Wanting to Know'
The Production Mechanism of Taboos — Who Decides What 'Must Not Be Said'
Literature Map of Agnotology in the Japanese-speaking World 2022–2026 — Tracing the Birth of a Discipline
Japan's Structural Reproduction of Climate Skepticism (How Doubt Circulates)
The Statistical Absence of Femicide (The Structure of Deaths That Cannot Be Counted)
The Monthly Labour Statistics Scandal and the Reproduction of State Ignorance — When the Numbers 'Did Not Exist'
Selective Description in Educational Curricula and the Filtering of Knowledge
"I Have No Recollection" — The Institutionalization Mechanism of Political Memory Denial
Information Literacy as Counter-Design: Curriculum Principles Centered on Epistemic Justice
Counter-Design Practices in Japan — A Structural Analysis of Domestic Attempts to Implement Epistemic Justice
A Methodology for International Comparison of Counter-Design — A Framework for Comparing Four Lineages that Implement Epistemic Justice
The Archaeology of Silence — Five Methods for Excavating What Was Never Debated
Cross-Axis Analysis of 22 Notes / Structural Patterns in Ignorance Production
The New Ignorance Produced by Algorithms — Filter Bubbles and Echo Chambers
Why Are the Voices of Persons with Disabilities Not Heard? — The Japanese Structure of Testimonial Injustice
'Kūki' and Sontaku — The Japanese Form of Pluralistic Ignorance
Why Unreported Issues Are Treated as 'Nonexistent' — Media Agenda-Setting and Invisibilization in Japan
Okinawa and Structural Ignorance — The Politics of Mainland Japan's 'Not Knowing'
Poverty and Epistemic Exclusion — The Structure of 'Being Unable Even to Know'
Why Predatory Business Endures — Structural Analysis of Converting Information Asymmetry into Profit
The Doubt Manufacturing Industry — The Sixty-Year War of Tobacco and Climate
From 'Merchants of Doubt' to 'Captors of Regulation' — Reading Big AI's Regulatory Capture through 27 Mechanisms
Participate in & Support Research
If you're interested in ISVD's research, we welcome your support as a supporting member.
Other ISVD Labs
Separate research projects. Click to navigate to a different study.
Interested in this research?
We welcome researchers and practitioners to participate. You can contribute through joint research, data provision, fieldwork, and more.
Discuss research participationTags
Research Artifacts
- 1.1Conceptual Framework
- 1.2Literature Map
- 1.3Key Concepts
- 1.4.1Research Framework of the Agnotology Lab — An Inductive Coding Framework
- 1.4.2AI Amplification of the Brandolini Asymmetry — When the Cost of Producing Lies Approaches Zero
- 1.4.3Epistemic Injustice and Information Access Gaps in NPOs — Visualizing Structures Where Voices Go Unheard
- 1.4.4The Inhibitory Effect of Strategic Ignorance in EBPM — How 'Pretending Not to Know' Distorts Policy
- 2.1Critique Framework
- 2.2Case Analysis
- 2.3Critique Notes
- 3.1Synthesis Framework
- 3.2Theory Notes
- 3.3Counter-Design Proposal
- 4.1Publication Outline
- 4.2Academic Paper
- 4.3Public Report
- 5.1Discourse Article
- 5.2Lecture Materials
- 5.3Educational Tools